Compare financial options
Choose the objective, align the term, calculate each model and interpret the difference
- Choose the comparison For a purchase, compare total costs. For an investment under the stated model, compare final amounts. State the criterion before ranking the options
- Use a common term Use the same starting amount and elapsed time. Include every stated fee and payment, with its timing and frequency
- Count fees separately A one-off fee is charged once. A monthly fee charged at each month-end is charged twelve times over twelve months \(\displaystyle C=P+F+mn\)
- Distinguish interest from the balance The final amount includes the original principal. Interest earned is the final amount minus that principal \(\displaystyle I=A-P\)
- Match the rate and period Use the rate for one update and the number of those updates. A rate already given per quarter is not divided by four again \(\displaystyle A=P(1+i)^n\)
- Keep the model explicit Use the stated rounding convention. In an ideal full-precision model, round a final money report once. A numerical ranking alone does not account for affordability, risk or unstated charges
Worked example
An ideal $2,000 investment is held for three years. Option A pays 4% simple interest per year; Option B pays 4% per year compounded annually. There are no fees or other cash flows. Which gives the greater final amount?
- \(\displaystyle A_A=2000(1+0.04\times3)=2240\)Simple interest uses the original principal each year
- \(\displaystyle A_B=2000(1.04)^3=2249.728\)Compound interest uses the updated balance. Retain full precision
- \(\displaystyle A_B-A_A=9.728\)Option B gives the greater final amount, by $9.73 when the difference is reported to cents
Common mistakes
Difficulty levels
Questions about this topic
Is the lowest rate always cheapest?+
No. Compare totals over the same term, including all stated charges and their timing
When do I choose the larger amount?+
When the stated objective is a greater investment balance or return. For a purchase-cost comparison, a smaller total cost is preferred under the model
Do I divide a quarterly rate by four?+
Not if it is already stated per quarter. Use the supplied quarterly rate and count quarters
Should I round each update?+
Follow the stated convention. The fixed teaching examples use ideal full-precision calculations with final rounding only
Does a cheaper total settle a real purchasing decision?+
No. The model may omit affordability, risk, flexibility or other conditions. A written justification must identify relevant assumptions
Can I use a calculator?+
A calculator is allowed unless a question is marked no calculator
Which year level and chapter is this?+
Year 11, VCE Units 1 & 2, General Mathematics, chapter 3: Sequences and finance